[Appeared in The Guardian, November 2011]
Last month's shadow cabinet reshuffle saw Harriet Harman take on the role of shadow secretary of state for culture, media and sport, while Dan Jarvis, who was elected MP for Barnsley Central in a by-election in March this year, has been made shadow culture minister. Neither of them have any experience in the culture sector; Jarvis, in fact, has very little experience in any sector other than the armed forces, having served until very recently as a soldier with the Parachute Regiment, a career he has pursued since leaving university.
And meanwhile in government we have Jeremy Hunt as Harman's opposite number, with Ed Vaizey as minister for culture, communications and the creative industries. These two fare little better in the culture stakes.
To sum up the current situation as it stands then, neither the individuals with ultimate responsibility for the future of the arts in this country, nor the ministers charged with holding the government to account for its culture sector policies have any practical experience of the fields they lead.
Perhaps this isn't such a problem. After all, we don't require our education ministers to have worked in schools or our energy secretaries to have run power stations. Indeed, there are plenty of politicians who, having gone straight into politics out of university, have no career experience outside the world of politics at all. Our civil servants are a very able bunch, well versed in bringing ministers up to speed on the particulars of their new appointments. You might even argue that there's a benefit to looking on a subject, particularly one as emotive and personal as the arts, with fresh eyes.
It's hardly contentious to suggest, however, that those who can draw upon some relevant practical experience will be at an advantage when it comes to making complex policy decisions, whatever department they are leading. This is particularly the case with the culture sector, I'd argue, because of the nature of the arts themselves. I want the people fighting the corner for theatre, visual arts, music and museums, to have had a taste of the unique thrills and frustrations of the creative sectors, to have witnessed at first hand the extraordinary way that the arts affect individuals and communities. It doesn't much matter the role they've played in the arts, I don't think, just that they've been there and seen it for themselves.
Of course practical experience isn't everything; political experience of an area of policy is also crucial. Which is why I'm also concerned by the fact that both Miliband's new culture appointments come to these roles from government sectors worlds away from the arts. This is clearly something that Jarvis himself is aware of: the week after the reshuffle the minister wrote on his blog that he had received various messages via Twitter and Facebook professing surprise at his appointment. Jarvis responded by drawing attention to a “picture competition” and an Olympics digital bursary scheme he launched in his constituency as evidence of his experience with cultural policy. Valuable schemes I'm sure, but you can hardly call Jarvis an arts policy expert.
I'm not trying to get at Jarvis here – it's hard to fault the enthusiasm with which he's been throwing himself into his new role – but I can't help but feel that his and Harman's appointments are cynical ones, more to do with the power play of cabinet politics than the good of the culture sector itself. Are they really the best people to stand up for the arts in the face of the government's argument that cuts are the only way forward? Or would ministers with a wealth of relevant practical and political experience be better? What do you think?
Comments
Sign up or log in to post something
Log in to your account
Sign up: It's free and anyone can join.
Verify your account
Nearly there! We've sent you an email – just click on the link in the email to verify your account and you'll then be a fully fledged member of IdeasTap.
If you can't find the email in your inbox, check your spam folder - if it's in there, save the address in your contacts. That way you'll always get our emails.
If you're still having problems, email us at info@ideastap.com.